Vetnuus | July 2026 25 Article characteristics may balance each other out. Therefore, after controlling for differences in dog-keeping practices between mixed-breeds and purebreds, we expected no differences between the mean behavioural trait scores of a large population of mixed-breed dogs and purebred dogs. The gene flow between the two populations also favours this hypothesis. Purebreds generally originated from ancient mixed-breeds, and mixed-breeds often have purebreds among their ancestors. Two surveys were developed, both measuring the demographic characteristics of the owners and dogs, as well as the dog-keeping practices. Survey 1 aimed at measuring the dogs’ general behaviour tendencies (personality), and Survey 2, typical behaviour problems. Materials and methods Ethics statement We collected the data using an online questionnaire designed to assess the dogs’ behaviour via owner report. According to the currently operating Hungarian law (‘‘1998. e´vi XXVIII.To¨rve´ny”—the Animal Protection Act, 3rd paragraph, 9th point), non-invasive observational experiments on dog behaviour are not considered as animal experiments and are therefore allowed to be conducted without any special permission from the University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (UIACUC). The filling out of the questionnaires was voluntary and anonymous, so the study did not violate respondents’ privacy. Informed consent was included in the introductory letter of the questionnaires. Subjects We used the questionnaire method because it allowed us to collect data from a large number of subjects, who were highly diverse in terms of breed and dog-keeping practices. A total of 14,004 dog owners filled out the first survey, and 10,240 filled out the second. We excluded reports with missing data and repetitions (where owners filled in two or more reports about the same dog; we used these data only for calculating test-retest and inter-rater reliability). There were N = 312 owners who filled in both surveys; their demographic and dog-keeping questions were considered only once. We grouped the dogs into purebred and mixed-breed groups based on the owners’ specifications. To control for the effect of breed popularity in the purebred group, we defined a cutoff point for both surveys, so that the maximum number of individuals in a given breed was N = 60 for Survey 1 and N = 37 for Survey 2. We determined the cut-off point to match the total number of individuals in the purebred and mixed-breed groups. If a breed was represented with more individuals than the cut-off point, we selected a random sample for the final dataset. The final sample of Survey 1 consisted of N = 9186 dogs (4593 in the purebred and 4593 in the mixed-breed groups). The purebred group was composed of 254 breeds, and no breeds had more than 60 representatives. The final sample of Survey 2 had N = 6384 dogs (N = 3199 dogs in the purebred and N = 3185 dogs in the mixed-breed group). The purebred group was composed of 251 breeds, and no breeds had more than 37 representatives. Descriptive information of the databases can be found in the supplemental material (S1 and S2 Tables). Procedure We conducted two surveys in Germany, both of which were developed by Jesko Wilke, a freelance journalist of the German ‘Dogs’ magazine. The data were collected online by the magazine’s own website (www. dogs-magazin.de). The results of Survey 1 have already been published in [9] and [27]. Both surveys comprised two parts. The first part collected information about the demographic characteristics of the owners and dogs, as well as about dog-keeping practices. Twelve of these questions were the same in both surveys; eight were present in only one. The second part differed between the two surveys. Survey 1 aimed at measuring the dogs’ general behaviour tendencies (personality) and was developed based on a human personality inventory. This questionnaire contained 24 items (e.g. “My dog is calm, even in ambiguous situations”), and for each item, the owners were asked to indicate their level of agreement on a 3-point scale (true, partly true, and not true) (see S3 Table). Our previous results using principal component analysis have revealed that 17 items out of the 24 belonged to four components, labelled as calmness, trainability, dog sociability, and boldness, all traits with middle or high internal consistency ([9,27], S3 Table). Survey 2 listed 12 examples of typical behavioural problems such as “My dog usually does not listen to me when I call him/her back” (S4 Table). Again, the owners indicated for each statement how much they agree with it using a 3-point scale. The questions were designed to assess not only the prevalence of behavioural problems of the dogs, but also the owners’ attitude towards these behaviours; i.e. if he/she considers them problematic. The internal consistency of the 12 items of the “Problematic behaviour” scale (Cronbach’s alpha = 0.720) indicates that they form one single trait referring to how problematic the owners assess their dogs’behaviour in general. We calculated the trait scores of Survey 1 and Survey 2 by taking the mean of the variables belonging to a given trait. We used the multiple reports from the same owner about the same dog (N = 208 in Survey 1 and N = 280 in Survey 2) for calculating testretest reliability, and reports collected from a second owner (of the same dog) (N = 85 in Survey 1 and N = 136 in Survey 2) for assessing inter-rater reliability of the surveys. Statistical analyses Reliability analyses of the surveys. We analysed the test-retest and inter-rater reliability of the surveys using Intraclass correlations (test-retest: Two-Way Mixed model, consistency; inter-rater: One-Way Random model, absolute agreement). Behaviour trait differences between the dog groups. The data were analysed at the individual level with each dog as a separate data point. To analyse the difference between the purebred and mixed-breed dogs, we compared the five behavioural traits (the four personality traits from Survey 1 and the Problematic behaviour trait from Survey 2) between the dog groups using independent-samples t-tests, and the effect size was estimated using Cohen’s d. Demographic and dog-keeping differences between the dog groups. For the twelve questions which were common between the >>>26
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=