Vetnews | Julie 2026 24 « BACK TO CONTENTS Article Borba´la Turcsa´n1,2*, A´da´m Miklo´si1,3, Enikő Kubinyi1 1 Department of Ethology, Eo¨tvo¨s Lora´nd University, Budapest, Hungary, 2 Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience and Psychology, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary, 3 MTA-ELTE Comparative Ethological Research Group, Budapest, Hungary * borbala.turcsan@gmail.com Owner perceived differences between mixedbreed and purebred dogs Abstract Studies about the behaviours of mixed-breed dogs are rare, although mixed-breeds represent the majority of the world’s dog population. We have conducted two surveys to investigate the behavioural, demographic, and dog-keeping differences between purebred and mixed-breed companion dogs. Questionnaire data were collected on a large sample of dogs living in Germany (N = 7,700 purebred dogs representing more than 200 breeds, and N = 7,691 mixed breeds). We found that according to their owners, mixed-breeds were (1) less calm, (2) less sociable toward other dogs, and (3) showed more problematic behaviour than purebreds (p < 0.001 for all). Mixed-breeds and purebreds were similar in trainability and boldness scores. However, twelve out of 20 demographic and dog-keeping factors differed between purebred and mixed-breed dogs, and two factors showed considerable (> 10%) differences: neutering was more frequent among mixed-breeds, and they were acquired at older ages than purebreds (p < 0.001 for both), which could result in the observed behaviour differences. After controlling for the distribution of the demographic and dogkeeping factors, we found that mixed breeds were (1) more trainable than purebreds, (2) less calm, and (3) showed more problematic behaviour than purebreds (p < 0.001 for all). We discuss that these differences at least partly might be due to selective forces. Our results suggest that instead of being the “average” dogs, mixed-breeds represent a special group with characteristic behavioural traits. Introduction When it comes to selecting a new canine companion, choosing an incompatible breed could have dire consequences regarding the wellbeing of both the owner and the dog. Although the typical behaviour of different dog breeds has attracted considerable scientific attention (e.g. [1]), studies about mixed-breed dogs are rare. Mixed-breed dogs comprise dogs of heterogeneous origin that, by definition, belong to no recognised breed, and their ancestry is usually complex or unknown. They could be intentionally bred by humans as hybrids of recognised breeds (e.g. ‘designer dogs’), they could be offspring of a purebred and a mixed-breed dog, offspring of two mixed-breeds, or descendants of stray, feral or pariah dog populations. The percentage of mixed-breed dogs (out of all dogs living in households in the USA) is estimated to be around 53% by the American Veterinary Medical Association [2], and 44% by an analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. The American Pet Products Association [3]. In Germany and in the UK, approximately 31– 33% of dogs are mixed-breeds [4,5], while in Australia, mixed-breeds make up half of the population of dogs living in human households [6]. In scientific databases, mixed-breeds compose approximately one third of the dogs [7–9]. However, these proportions are likely to underestimate the real number of mixed-breeds in the whole dog population, considering that these data estimate only the “owned” dog population (based on pet industry reports, veterinary records, household panels or mail surveys [10]). The mixed-breeds’ contribution to the stray, feral and pariah dog populations is hard to estimate reliably. However, they probably represent the majority of dogs worldwide [11]. Mixed-breeds are often assumed to have some phenotypic advantage over purebreds in terms of fitness (e.g. improved health and lower susceptibility to diseases), because they show a lower level of homozygosity and have much higher genetic variation [12–14], which could lead to hybrid vigour [15]. Some studies have reported that adult mixed-breed dogs are less likely to suffer from inherited genetic diseases and live longer than purebreds [12,16–18]. Several studies have detected behavioural differences between mixed-breed and purebred dogs. For example, Bennett and Rholf [7] reported mixedbreeds to be more disobedient, more nervous, more excitable, and exhibited excessive barking more frequently in the case of mixedbreeds than in purebred dogs. Hsu and Sun [19] reported higher ranks for three aggression subscales in mixed breeds (towards strangers, towards dogs, and towards owner/s). Mixed-breeds have also been reported to have an increased risk of developing noise phobia [20]; they were more likely to be aggressive toward unfamiliar people, more fearful, and more sensitive to touch than purebreds [21]. Temesi et al. [22] found higher neuroticism, dog-directed fear and human-directed fear in mixed-breeds than in all AKC breed groups except the Toy dogs group. On the other hand, Ottenheimer-Carrier et al. [23] did not find any differences between purebred and mixed-breed dogs in three personality assessments. One should note, however, that the main aim of these studies was not to compare purebreds and mixed-breeds. Therefore, these results could reflect a number of other systematic differences between these dog groups apart from the dogs’ purebred status. For example, dog keeping practices have been reported in association with numerous behaviour traits (e.g. [9,24– 26]); therefore, differences in these factors could result in behaviour differences between mixed-breeds and purebreds. In the current study, we explored possible differences between mixedbreeds and purebreds in various behaviour traits and dog-keeping characteristics. We hypothesised that when numerous individuals from many breeds are investigated together, breed-specific behavioural
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=