Vetnews | Julie 2026 26 « BACK TO CONTENTS Article Owner perceived differences between mixed-breed and purebred dogs.... <<< 25 two surveys, we pooled the data of the two surveys. The categorical variables were compared between the dog groups (purebred and mixed-breed) using Chi-squared tests with a post hoc test, and the age of the dogs in the two groups was compared using the Mann-Whitney U test. For the comparisons of the demographic and dog keeping factors, we provided unstandardized effect size statistics (i.e. the magnitude of the difference between the groups), since we deemed them more meaningful in this case than standardised measures [28]. Relationship between the behaviour differences and demographic/ dog keeping differences. We analysed the associations between the behavioural traits and demographic and dog-keeping factors using five general linear models (GLM). In each model, the dependent variable was the behavioural trait, and the explanatory factors included the dog group (purebred and mixed-breed) as a fixed factor, and all the demographic and dog-keeping factors in which significant differences were found between the dog groups (age as a covariate, and categorical variables as fixed factors). The aim of these GLM analyses was not only to investigate how the demographic and dog-keeping factors are associated with the behavioural traits, but also to investigate if the behaviour differences between the dog groups remain significant when controlling for any differences in the demographic and dogkeeping factors. We also added all two-way interactions between the dog group and the demographic / dog keeping factors. A significant interaction would mean that a given factor has a different relationship with the behavioural trait in purebreds than in mixed-breeds. Non-significant interactions were removed from the model sequentially in the order of their decreasing significance; however, all main effects, even nonsignificant ones, were left in the model. The effect size of each factor in the final model was estimated with partial eta squared, which reflects the proportion of total variation attributable to a given explanatory factor when excluding other factors in the model from the total nonerror variation [29].In order to take into account the large number of subjects investigated and the multiple statistical analyses performed, we set the threshold of the significance level to p = 0.00037 (0.05 /134) according to the Bonferroni correction method. Statistical analyses were performed with SPSS version 22. Results Reliability analyses of the surveys Both the inter-observer reliability and the test-retest reliability of the five traits were excellent (Table 1). Behaviour trait differences between the dog groups In Survey 1, mixed-breed dogs were rated to be less calm (t-test, N = 9,186, t = 14.910; p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.311) and less sociable toward other dogs (t = 4.919; p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.103) than purebred dogs. We found no significant difference in trainability (t = 1.946; p = 0.052) or boldness (t = 0.519; p = 0.604) traits between the dog groups. In Survey 2, owners of mixed-breeds reported their dogs’ behaviour as more problematic (t-test, N = 6,384, t = 5.577; p < 0.001, Cohen’s d = 0.140) than the owners of purebreds. Demographic and dog-keeping differences between the dog groups We found significant differences between purebred and mixed-breed dogs in 12 out of the 20 investigated demographic and dog-keeping factors (Table 2), after correcting for multiple comparisons. Ten of these factors were common between the two surveys, and two factors were investigated in Survey 2 only. However, due to the large sample size, even with the p < 0.00037 threshold, a significant result in most of the factors indicated only a small (3–6%) difference in a given category between the dog groups. Regarding the demographic factors, mixedbreed dogs were found to be older in our sample, and there were more females among them than among purebreds. Mixed-breed owners were more likely to be women, they were younger, had a lower level of education and had less previous experience with dogs than the owners of purebreds. However, we found no difference between the groups in the number of adults and children in the household.Regarding the dog keeping factors: mixed-breeds were more likely to be neutered, owners acquired them at an older age, they received less training, and they were more likely to be kept only indoors and as single dogs than purebred dogs. However, mixed-breed owners walked their dogs for longer than the owners of purebreds. We found no difference between the groups in how much time the owners spend with their dog in general, or with playing, for what purpose the owners keep the dog, whether they buy gifts for the dog and whether the dog is allowed onto the bed. (Table 2). Relationship between the behavioural traits and the demographic/dog keeping factors When controlling for all demographic and dog-keeping factors, where the difference between the dog groups was significant in our previous analysis (10 factors for the traits from Survey 1 and 12 factors for the Problematic behaviour trait from Survey 2 see Table 2), we found that the dogs’ breeding status was still significantly associated with the calmness and problematic behaviour traits (Table 3), and interestingly, it was also significant for trainability. Calmness Trainability Dog sociability Boldness Problematic behaviour Inter-observer reliability (ICC 1,k) ICC 0.830 0.753 0.849 0.874 0.766 F F84,85 = 5.881 F84,85 = 4.046 F84,85 = 6.640 F84,85 = 7.939 F135,136 = 4.265 p < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 Test-retest reliability (ICC 3,k) ICC 0.899 0.886 0.944 0.912 0.911 F F207,207 = 9.923 F207,207 = 8.791 F207,207 = 17.788 F207,207 = 11.399 F279,279 = 11.206 p < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 Table 1. Reliability measures of the five behaviour traits. >>>28
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=