VN February 2023

Vetnews | February 2023 19 Therefore, some have proposed understanding health as resilience within the One Health framework. Resilience can be interpreted as a system’s persistence and ability to absorb change and disturbance and maintain the same relationships between populations or state variables. From this perspective, one can, for instance, learn that external forces in intensive livestock farming, like insufficient housing, food and management, have outbalanced the internal capacities of animals to react and stay healthy. Current animal production systems are developed to maximise production and efficacy under standard conditions, which makes them vulnerable to (unanticipated) external influences. Inadequate functioning or overstimulation over longer periods can lead to disease. These production-related diseases can therefore be considered a sign that current intensive animal production systems are not resilient. Resilience can be presented as a universal criterion for health. Emphasis is placed on the importance of an animal’s ability to react, balance and restore itself to a certain degree, given that the surroundings allow this to reach a status that can be described as healthy. This view is compatible with modern definitions of animal welfare, of which health is an inseparable part. Arguments are that an individual animal is in a positive welfare state when it is free to display normal behavioural patterns. It can adapt to the demands of the prevailing environmental circumstances and reach a state that the animal perceives as positive. Nowadays, comparable balance theories of health are also prominent in human medicine. It is advocated to define health as the ability to adapt and self-manage. The concept of resilience is applied to characterise the health of ecosystems. An ecological system is healthy if it is stable and sustainable, i.e. if it is active, maintains its organisation and autonomy over time, and is resilient to stress. Since it is universally applicable to humans, animals and the environment, we believe the idea of health as resilience contributes to operationalising a One Health strategy to tackle antimicrobial resistance. It is because, in the context of animal husbandry, it provides grounds to transform animal production systems in a way that the resilience of animals is promoted. Consequently, human and environmental health will benefit from this as well. Veterinary Organisations and One Health With its specific expertise, the veterinary profession is qualified to guide this transition towards sustainable animal husbandry in which antimicrobial use can be minimised further. For individual veterinarians starting this process can be problematic. It is not rooted in moral indifference. Most veterinarians’ main concern is the health and welfare of the animals under their care. However, the influence of farm animal veterinarians is sometimes limited because of their role as service-provider: they provide veterinary care at the request of farmers. Farmers primarily expect veterinarians to do what they are called to do. Therefore, interventions are sometimes only directed at solving disease problems in the short term. Of course, veterinarians will advise farmers on how to prevent diseases and have healthier animals in the long term. However, this can be difficult because, in this context, veterinarians depend on the will and the (financial) possibilities of farmers to change circumstances for the better of their animals. Moreover, public health problems like antimicrobial resistance are of global concern and go beyond the sphere of influence of individual veterinarians. On such a scale, their impact is limited. Although the commitment of individual veterinarians is essential in national reduction policies, a more collective approach is necessary to effectively address the issue of antimicrobial resistance on a global level. Therefore, we propose to start this change at the level of professional organisations of veterinarians. They have different roles to play. They can translate veterinary concerns into position papers that transcend the problems on individual farms. Veterinary organisations should publicly address structural underlying causes in the food production chain that precede diseases in animals. They should call on all responsible parties in the food production chain (farmers’ organisations, food producers, banks and retail) as well as the government and consumers to take action. By doing so, veterinary associations will support individual veterinarians in their daily work to improve animal health and welfare on the farm level. Veterinarians truly contribute to the idea of One Health if they collectively promote livestock systems that are not primarily focused on production results and cost reduction but on animal health and welfare. However, not many veterinary organisations publicly address the problems of intensive animal husbandry in the name of One Health. Like many individual farm animal veterinarians, national veterinary professional organisations seem reticent to take an explicit stand for animal health and welfare. In 2017, theWorldVeterinary Association (WVA) adopted the so-called Incheon declaration that described the veterinary profession’s role in One Health and Eco Health initiatives. The WVA emphasises the importance of policy engagement and professional leadership to address One Health issues. Moreover, the veterinary profession should assertively advocate for and protect the welfare of all animals living in all environments. Veterinarians are educated to evaluate animal health and welfare skillfully, dependent upon proper housing, management, nutrition, disease prevention and treatment, responsible care and humane handling. With antimicrobial resistance, the FVE endorsed the idea that prevention is better than cure by stating that animals that are well cared for and appropriately housed will experience Veterinarians truly contribute to the idea of One Health if they collectively promote livestock systems that are not primarily focused on production results and cost reduction Antimicrobial resistance is of global concern Animal production must promote resilience The concept of resilience can be applied to all components of One Health: humans, animals and ecosystems. Current intensive animal production systems are not resilient FVE recommends promoting positive welfare steps to reduce stress Article >>> 20

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=