VN February 2023
Vetnuus | Februarie 2023 20 better welfare, be less prone to infections and will need fewer antimicrobials. FVE acknowledges the need to improve biosecurity and hygiene in animal husbandry to reduce bacterial infections and complementary treatments with antimicrobials. Moreover, FVE recommends promoting positive welfare steps to reduce stress and susceptibility to infections. Besides productivity, farm animal breeders should incorporate breeding goals on health and longevity, including disease resistance, to decrease the need for antimicrobial treatments. In a recent position paper on disease surveillance, the BVA acknowledges the importance of animal health and welfare for public health and trade in animal products. In line with OIE, they advocate the important role of veterinarians in monitoring diseases by acting as a sentinel for wider human and animal health, underpinned by a common‘One Health’rationale tominimise harm. Although improvement of veterinary surveillance will certainly contribute to animal- and public health, unfortunately, in this paper, the BVA did not point out the underlying reasons for many public health threats originating from intensive livestock farming. It may be a missed opportunity to fundamentally apply One Health thinking. Of course, occasionally, individual veterinarians have spoken out for preventive population health to reduce the need for curative interference, like prescribing antimicrobials. However, on the level of national veterinary organisations worldwide, there seems to be relative silence about the need to change livestock production in the context of One Health. One of the reasons for this could be that just like veterinarians, who are financially dependent on their clients, veterinary organisations are equally dependent on their members. Without a considerable representationof the veterinaryprofession, veterinaryorganisations often do not successfully influence policy-making and contribute to public debate. Furthermore, because of differentiation and specialisation in the profession, veterinary organisations have a very diverse membership. For instance, companion animal veterinarians often have totally different views about the ethical acceptability of livestock production systems than their colleagues in farm animal medicine. This moral plurality sometimes makes it difficult to publish very pronounced statements. Professional Integrity and Leadership In the case of antimicrobial resistance, the relationship between veterinarian and farmer greatly influences the success of reduction policies. An important factor here is the level of independence and authority of veterinarians to resist the demand of certain farmers to prescribe antimicrobials when there is no strict veterinary need. In this context, the notion of professional integrity plays an important role. When veterinarians are confronted with a conflict of interest between the profession’s core values (animal health, animal welfare and public health), they have to be able to balance between accommodation of their client’s wishes and professional integrity. Professional integrity, in terms of a commitment to the profession’s aims and principles, can help veterinarians to motivate their actions and to show why decisions are not just arbitrary or opportunistic. Professional standards or position papers can support individual veterinarians with these often difficult decisions on the farm. In the Netherlands, veterinary organisations often cooperate with farmer organisations and pharmaceutical industry representatives to realise their goals. At the same time, they consult with the government and animal welfare organisations. The influence of veterinary organisations and whether they are successful in promoting the interests of their members depends greatly on the relationship with these stakeholders. However, just like individual veterinarians, veterinary organisations should be aware of maintaining their integrity. Certain independence of veterinary organisations is a prerequisite to preserving the general public’s trust. For this reason, the profession needs a well- functioning self-regulatory system. To promote the long-term interests of the veterinary profession, veterinary organisations should overcome the short-term (economic) interests of some individual members or certain stakeholders. Instead, veterinary organisations must develop and show professional leadership to meet societal expectations and maintain professional autonomy. Rather than addressing symptoms and solving moral problems that arise from intensive livestock farming, this idea of leadership entails that the veterinary profession makes these moral issues, including the underlying system problems, visible to society. This step is not a kind of buck-passing but shows that dealing with current challenges cannot be a task for farmers and veterinarians only. After all, societal developments and demands shape existing livestock production systems. Therefore the responsibility for innovation and transformation of livestock farming into a practice that does justice to human, animal and ecosystem health is not restricted to one group in society but requires an integrated approach. Still, in this debate, the veterinary profession has an independent position to promote animal health, which arises from their professional veterinary responsibilities. By doing so, they encapsulate human and environmental health as well. Conclusion One Health strategies are indispensable to tackle zoonotic disease threats from intensive livestock farming, like antimicrobial resistance. However, the One Health concept does not yet prescribe exactly how the relationship between human, animal and ecosystemhealth should be shaped to address zoonotic diseases fundamentally. We argue that these health issues require a system-level approach. Furthermore, using an integrated view of health is essential rather than focusing solely on human health. Veterinary organisations have to develop and show professional leadership to meet societal expectations Promote animal health! Article Professional integrity can help veterinarians to motivate their actions and to show why decisions are not just arbitrary Relative silence exists about the need to change livestock production in the context of One Health
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=