VN February 2023

Vetnuus | Februarie 2023 18 As a result, until 2007, the Netherlands led the European charts of antimicrobial use in farm animals. It is clear that using antimicrobials in animals causes antimicrobial resistance in pathogenic and commensal bacteria in animals. Although it is difficult to prove a direct link between the use of antimicrobials in farm animals and antimicrobial resistance in human patients, there is scientific and public consensus on the importance of restrictive use of antimicrobials in animal husbandry due to its potential impact on public health. Especially the misuse of antimicrobials in healthy animals is considered a threat to human health because of the possible loss of effective antimicrobials for human medicine. Because of this risk, the Dutch government has issued strict animal antimicrobial use policies. It resulted in the so-called ‘Dutch Model’, which appeared to be very effective and significantly reduced antimicrobial use. Internationally this policy has even been presentedas anexampleof antimicrobial reductionpolicies inanimal husbandry. The success of the strategy can be partly attributed to a stronger position of veterinarians on farms (mandatory one-on- one contract, herd health plan and regular farm visits), registration and benchmarking of antimicrobial use, vaccination strategies and better biosecurity. Although initially, farmers and veterinarians were worried about the negative effects of antimicrobial reduction policies, it seems that, to date, there is little evidence that animal health is seriously affected. Apparently, veterinarians and farmers were able to safeguard animal health in other ways, such as vaccination and improving biosecurity. It seems to fit perfectly in a One Health perspective because eventually, the health of humans, animals and the environment has benefited from reducing antimicrobial use. However, despite the success, new questions arise. Dutchpoliticians argued that antimicrobial consumption in livestock should be as low as possible to protect public health. As a result, the current question in the Netherlands is whether it is possible to reduce antimicrobial use further than the 64,4% decrease achieved so far (year of reference 2009). The Dutch government and the Veterinary Medicines Authority both indicate that additional reduction is indeed possible, certainly on farms that currently are registered as structural high users. It will probably be true, although it is unrealistic to expect that antimicrobial use in animals could be banned. As long as society considers livestock farming socially and ethically acceptable, a certain amount of antimicrobials will always be necessary to treat bacterial infections in farm animals. Veterinarians are regarded as a key factor in current and future antimicrobial reduction policies in the Netherlands. Still, even on farms with a structural high use, veterinarians will consider it their professional responsibility to treat sick animals with antimicrobials. So as long as farmers are unwilling or able to implement the veterinarian’s advice about alternative measures to prevent bacterial infections, it won’t be easy to make further progress. It is therefore argued that to achieve a level of antimicrobial use in livestock farming that can be considered as low as reasonably possible requires an approach on a system level. In our view, the main underlying problem in livestock farming is a one-sided focus on maximising production at minimum costs to produce cheap animal protein. It leads to animal health (and -welfare) problems and risks. Moreover, it substantially reduces the farmers’ability to change and innovate. Consequently, veterinarians’ recommendations to make more fundamental changes in management or housing to reduce disease problems are not followed. Quite often, this is not a problem of the unwillingness of farmers but the result of financial inability. Since veterinarians still consider it their moral obligation to treat sick animals, this situation forces them to prescribe antimicrobials, which brings along human health risks. To stop this race to the bottom, a holistic view of the One Health perspective can teach us two lessons. First , it is necessary to address the fundamental problems of intensive livestock farming rather than attempting to maintain animal health using antimicrobials under difficult circumstances. Second , the dichotomy from which it seems one has to choose between human and animal health must be eliminated. If we address the cost-only perspective of animal husbandry and start from an ‘encapsulated health’ perspective, i.e., keeping our animals healthy and caring for their welfare, thiswill automatically contribute to reducing zoonotic disease risks and thereby promote human health. In this process, veterinarians should play an important role. They already have the Aesculapian authority to inform the public about the underlying causes of problems, such as antimicrobial resistance, to start a change. Health: a Matter of Resilience A holistic conception of One Health could provide veterinarians with other tools to address the negative aspects of intensive livestock farming and to stimulate more sustainable and socially acceptable production systems. A prerequisite of such a system would be: not to harm the health of humans, animals and the environment. Therefore, the starting point for any livestock production system should be that the health of animals is central. However, One Health does not come with a standard definition of health. Nonetheless, conceptual clarity on this level is important to respond to problems such as antimicrobial resistance in a way that takes animals, humans and nature into account. There are many definitions of human, animal and environmental health. In veterinary medicine, health is sometimes defined in terms of production or reproduction. From this perspective, one could maintain that a focus on production automatically implies that animals must be healthy if a farmer wants to keep their farm profitable. However, pushing animals towards high productivity increases the risk of certain diseases. Within the context of zoonotic diseases and antimicrobial resistance, it seems appropriate to understand health as the absence of disease. This definition is understandable for veterinary practitioners and gives them a reason to promote disease prevention. However, applying this definition to characterise the health of ecosystems is difficult because bacteria and viruses that can cause (zoonotic) diseases are essential to balanced ecosystems. Aesculapianauthority is the uniquely powerful authority vested in those that society perceives as healers, historically traceable to the timewhen medicinewas inseparable frommagic and religion. Article Veterinarians are regarded as a key factor in current and future antimicrobial reduction policies Animals could be safeguarded in other ways

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=