VN February 2023
Vetnuus | Februarie 2023 16 It is not only a public expectation, but it is also acknowledged as a professional responsibility. It is broadly recognised that with the veterinarian’s cross-species pathobiological expertise, they can make an essential contribution to public health. However, making all these veterinary responsibilities operational if concerns for the health of humans, animals and nature conflict is not easy. For example, in the case of antimicrobial resistance, this becomes apparent when vets prescribe antimicrobials like colistin to cure post-weaning diarrhoea (PWD) in piglets. PWD is an important economic problem in the swine industry, associated with a proliferation of enterotoxigenic E. coli bacteria in the pig intestine. Although treatment with antimicrobials like colistin is effective, its use has also led to developing (multi)resistant E. coli strains in swine. Moreover, antimicrobials such as colistin are considered a ‘last resort’ therapy for certain bacterial infections in human medicine. The discovery of new resistance genes, which can be easily transferred to other bacteria, has raised concerns about animal husbandry use. However, alternative strategies to control PWD are complex and costly and depend on the competence, possibilities and willingness of farmers. For this reason, alternative strategies to control PWD are not as effective as antimicrobials. Despite the risks to public health, veterinarians, therefore, still treat PWD with antimicrobials like colistin to safeguard the health and welfare of piglets. Many veterinarians are aware of this dilemma but feel that when they cannot change the circumstances responsible for the disease, they have a strong duty to ensure the health of the piglets. Therefore, they often do not see other options in the short term than to treat the piglets with antimicrobials. This example shows that veterinarians constantly struggle to balance all these different professional responsibilities. Many veterinarians have great difficulty weighing all the interests in play. Without bad intent, this sometimes leads to unintended (but foreseeable) negative consequences for either public or animal health. Decisions become even more complicated when other interests join in as well. Veterinarians working in the food industry context, for instance, also have to deal with the economic interests of farmers and other parties in the food chain. At first glance, it seems that One Health only adds up to this complexity. The One Health framework requires veterinarians to cooperate with other health professionals to combat zoonotic diseases to protect public health. Within a narrow interpretation of the One Health concept, this could imply that veterinarians should prevail human interests over animal health and welfare. However, we argue that these conflicts and difficulties are not the result of the One Health approach. It only makes the existing complexity explicit. What One Health has to Offer Clearly, in the cases described above, a straightforward application of the One Health concept will not lead to an easy fix. On the contrary, current interpretations of One Health give veterinarians little moral guidance to deal with the responsibility conflicts they experience. It specifies that human, animal and ecosystem health has to be addressed in an integrated way. Still, it does not yet prescribe how accurately the relation between human, animal and ecosystem health should be shaped. However, this step is essential to guide veterinarians in real-life cases, such as post-weaning diarrhoea. To find some common ground on the normative aspects of One Health, we start on the level where there is consensus. That is concerning the claim that it requires closer cooperation between veterinary and human medicine. In the case of zoonotic diseases, this resulted in sharing and assessing disease signals. However, although the importance of these integrated human-veterinary risk analysis structures cannot be denied, this only covers part of the answer because (a) the cooperation as such is not novel and (b) it represents a reactive strategy to address zoonotic health risks. Concerning the first point, the collaboration between veterinarians and human medicine is not as new as presented. In a historical analysis of zoonotic disease control in the Netherlands (1898– 2001), Haalboom concludes that interdisciplinary cooperation was not the biggest concern. She claims that the real problem of ineffective zoonotic disease control was an underlying conflict of interest between public health and the economic interests of the food industry. The serious consequences of these conflicts of interest became evident in the Q-fever epidemic that affected the Netherlands from 2007 to 2010. A difference of opinion between the Ministries of Health and Agriculture on the causality and the scientific evidence for interventions hindered an adequate approach. Finally, the continuous increase in human patients forced the government to cull 50,000 healthy and pregnant goats. Yet, there were indications that a vaccination strategy could have also stopped the epidemic if it had been applied earlier. This leads to the second problem: in its current form, cooperation leads to a reactive strategy to public health risks. Some interpretations of the One Health concept, especially in zoonotic disease control policies, suggest that veterinarians should mainly identify and combat zoonotic disease threats to human health. This view can be recognised in prominent One Health strategies to combat zoonotic diseases in livestock, like Avian Influenza, Q-fever or antimicrobial resistance. The focus is on public health, and the approach is primarily reactive and curative. Monitoring and controlling zoonotic diseases using methods like screening, animal movement restrictions, post-outbreak vaccination and culling is still standard in official Dutch as well as South African policy documents. The economic considerations that underlie the non-vaccination policies and EU- Regulations only further stress the central position that human interests have in the current situation. We agree on the importance of One Health in stimulating cooperation between specialisations and contributing to openness and combining How can the One Health concept support veterinarians in strengthening their position? Should human interests prevail over animal health and welfare Veterinarians are expected to promote public health and the health of the environment One Health may provide answers to mitigate the moral problems veterinarians face The approach is primarily reactive and curative Article
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=