VN February 2023

Vetnews | February 2023 15 Veterinary Responsibilities within the One Health Framework An extract from the publication: Food Ethics (2019) 3:109–123 https://doi.org/10.1007/s41055-019-00034-8 by J. van Herten & F. L. B. Meijboom Publishedonline on 28March2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/ s41055-019-00034-8#:~:text=The%20One%20 Health%20framework%20requires,over%20 animal%20health%20and%20welfare. Introduction Veterinarians play an essential role in the animal-based food chain. They are professionally responsible for the health of farm animals to secure food safety and public health. In the last decades, food scandals and zoonotic disease outbreaks have shown how much animal and human health are entangled. Therefore, the concept of One Health is broadly promoted within veterinary medicine. The profession embraces this idea that the health of humans, animals and the environment are inextricably linked and supports the related call for transdisciplinary collaboration. Especially in zoonotic disease control, the benefits of cooperation between veterinarians and human doctors seem evident. However, applying a One Health approach also makes moral problems explicit. For instance, how should veterinarians deal with situations where measures to protect public health negatively affect animal health? It creates a conflict of professional responsibilities. The starting point is a holistic perspective on One Health to deal with such moral problems and strengthen the veterinarian’s position. We will argue for an ‘encapsulated health’ argument: the best way to safeguard human health is to promote the health of animals and the environment. It also holds for the responsibility of the veterinary profession: “to serve public health” the central responsibility of veterinarians should be to be experts in animal health and welfare. The Royal Veterinary Association of the Netherlands (RVAN) motto is: ‘hominem animalumque saluti’, which stands for: ‘to the health of humans and animals’. This motto reflects the veterinary profession’s responsibility for the health of both humans and animals. In this case, the order of words might suggest that human health is the primary concern of veterinarians. However, in our opinion, the health of humans and animals should not be addressed separately, and the One Health paradigm seems to confirm this. Up till now, ideas about One Health have been developed in the context of zoonotic diseases. Comparative or translational medicine and the positive effects of interaction with animals on the health of humans in hospitals, prisons or elderly homes can all be covered under the One Health umbrella. This inclusion has recently led to a proposal to stretch the concept towards ‘One Welfare’. Veterinary Responsibilities Societal expectationswith regard to theprofessional responsibilities of veterinarians are changing. The work of veterinarians is no longer restricted to curative medicine in the interest of individual animals and their owners. A modern veterinarian must also be competent to take collective and global perspectives into account and be responsible for animal welfare and public health. Nowadays, veterinarians in animal food production also have to consider the interests of the food companies, retail, consumers and society. Mostly, neither veterinary legislation nor professional codes offer veterinarians much support in case of conflicting values or interests. In reality, many veterinarians are struggling with this plethora of responsibilities. In daily practice, veterinarians often have to deal with situations where human and animal interests are in conflict, and no easy solutions are available. Within the profession, this has opened the discussion on veterinary responsibilities and how to deal with expectations from society. In the Netherlands, for instance, an open letter from a group of veterinarians organised in ‘The Caring Vets’ led to an intense internal debate about the role of the profession in the transition towards amore sustainable type of animal husbandry. The Caring Vets claim that a veterinarian’s main interest should be animal welfare. Many Dutch farm animal veterinarians do not deny the importance of animal welfare. Still, they also consider themselves responsible for food safety, public health and increasing the economic profit of farmers. The tendency towards a stronger emphasis on the veterinary responsibility for animal welfare is also reflected by a position paper of the British Veterinary Association (BVA), in which the authors argue that neither emotions nor economic factors may trump animal welfare considerations (BritishVeterinary Association 2016). For instance, when a dog owner has emotional problems to euthanise their companion suffering from an incurable disease, this should not withhold a veterinarian from doing what is best for the animal. If the emotions of animal owners and societal expectations of the profession result in a conflict of professional responsibilities, this can be a source of moral dilemmas. TheBVAarguesthatimprovinganimalwelfareshouldbetheprofession’s primary aim and motivation. The profession’s increased concern for animal welfare seems one of the answers to deal with the complex societal expectations regarding veterinary responsibilities. However, if this would turn into a one-dimensional focus on either animal welfare or economics, it would do no justice to the broader spectrum of public expectations towards the veterinarian. Applying a One Health approach makes moral problems explicit Themostfundamentalquestionofveterinaryethics iswhetheraveterinarianmorallyowesprimary allegiancetowardstheownerortheanimal. >>> 16

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=