VN May 2021
Vetnews | May 2021 15 free” races, in which whips are held but not used, with “whipping- permitted” races. Races of these two types weremeticulouslymatched for racecourse, distance, number of runners, and “going” (turf conditions on the day). A detailed examination of stewards’post-race reports revealed no difference between the two race types in movement of horses across the track and interference with other runners, and therefore no evidence whipping improves safety. This adds to evidence from jumps racing that whip use is associated with catastrophic falls. 5. …or fairer… The gambling industry has an interest in ensuring races are run with integrity, lest punters take their dollars elsewhere. Whip use is arguably the most visible sign that jockeys are indeed trying their hardest. But the same study of stewards’ reports revealed no difference between “whipping-free” and conventional races in terms of the number of incidents related to jockey behaviour, such as careless riding or jockeys “dropping their hands” (indicative of not pushing the horse to run on). The key to a fair race is not encouraging jockeys to use the whip, but rather ensuring all jockeys are subject to the same rules. 6. … or faster The receivedwisdom is that whipping any horsemakes itmore likely to win. However, studies have shown increased whip use does not significantly affect speed at the finishing line, and the comparison study cited above found no difference in finishing times between whipping-free and conventional races. What’s more, in “hands and heels” races, the jockey’s centre of mass is likely to remain directly above the horse’s centre of mass for more of the time, compared with when the jockeys are whipping the horses. So, the biomechanics of whip-free racing are arguably better for equine performance. 7. Whip rules are hard to police The most prevalent breaches of the rules around whip use involve forehand strikes on more than five occasions before the 100-metre mark (44%), and the jockey’s arm being raised above shoulder height (24%). Studies of high-speed footage of 15 races revealed at least 28 rule breaches, involving nine horses, that were not recorded in stewards’ reports. There are two reasons for this: the footage seen by racing stewards is filmed head-on, and is recorded at fewer frames per second than high-resolution video now provides. Head-on footage is preferred by stewards as it allows estimations of whip use on both sides of the horse, but it makes it harder to accurately police other aspects of whip use, such as the use of excessive force. A separate study revealed more breaches are recorded at metropolitan than country or provincial racecourses, and by riders of horses that finished first, second, or third rather than in other positions. That said, horses that finished last were also worryingly vulnerable to whip-rule breaches. What’s more, even legal whipping is likely to cause significant pain, given the similarity of human and horse skin. 8. The public supports a ban on whipping In a recent independent poll of more than 1,500 Australian adults, 75% thought horses should not be hit with a whip in the normal course of a race. The survey also found men were more than twice as likely as women to support whipping racehorses. Even among respondents who attended races or gambled on them at least once a week, 30% disagreed with whipping. 9. Whip-free racing still allows betting While the ethics of promoting gambling is a different debate entirely, whip-free races in Norway and the UK still allow people to bet. It may even be more attractive to sponsors seeking assurance their brand is only associated with ethical activities. 10. Whipping tired animals in the name of sport is hard to justify Horses have evolved to run away from painful pressure on their hindquarters, given the most likely natural cause of such stimulation is contact from a predator. Repeatedly whipping tired horses in the closing stages of a race is likely to be distressing and cause suffering. The horse’s loss of agency as it undergoes repeated treatment of this sort is thought to lead to the state of “learned helplessness”, in which animals learn they can do nothing to end their distress. Racingmust reckonwith two key questions: does whipping actually work as intended, and is it an ethical way to treat a horse in the name of sport? If the answer to both of those is“no”, a third question arises: why are jockeys still doing it? v (Source: https://theconversation.com/10-reasons-to-stop- whipping-racehorses-including-new-research-revealing-the-likely- pain-it-causes-149271) Article
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=