VN May 2021
Vetnuus | Mei 2021 14 Our research, published in the journal Animals , shows horses’ skin is very similar to humans’ in both thickness and the arrangement of nerve endings. This adds to existing evidence that whipping is ineffective and unethical. Here we outline ten reasons why it’s time to drop the crop. 1. Horses’ skin appears just as sensitive as humans’ At the core of the debate is the question of whether horses experience pain when being whipped. A Sydney-based research team (of which one of us, Paul McGreevy, was a member) examined skin from 10 human cadavers and 20 euthanased horses under a microscope to explore any differences in their skin structure and nerve supply. The results revealed no significant difference between humans and horses in the concentration of nerve endings in the outer, surface layer of skin. 2. Horses’ skin is no thicker than humans’ The new study also found no significant difference between humans and horses in the average thickness of this outer layer. Horses need skin that is both robust and sensitive to touch, particularly from other horses or flying insects. The inner, base layer of skin in humans is significantly thinner than in horses, but this is not where the nerve endings lie. 3. Whip-free racing already exists Norway outlawed the whipping of racehorses in 1982. In the United Kingdom, “hands and heels” races for apprentice jockeys have been part of the racing calendar since 1999. These events, in which the least experienced (and presumably most vulnerable) jockeys race without using the whip, is at complete odds with the industry’s contention that whips are essential for steering and safety. There are no reports from Norway or the UK of problems in the conduct of these races. 4. There’s no evidence whips make racing safer… Whip use has been claimed to be essential for the safety of horses and jockeys. However, the impact of whip use on steering and safety had not been examined until a recent study compared “whipping- 10 reasons to stop whipping racehorses, including new research revealing the likely pain it causes Paul McGreevy, Professor of Animal Behaviour and Animal Welfare Science, University of Sydney and Bidda Jones, Honorary Associate in Animal Welfare, University of Sydney Pressure is increasing on the global horse-racing industry to reconsider the use of whips in the sport. Cross-sections of horse and human skin Microscopic cross-sections (400x magnification) of horse (left) and human skin. Images show the epidermis (top) and superficial dermis. Selected nerve endings are shown in red and marked with asterisks. Scale bars represent 20 micrometres. Tong et al. 2020, Author provided
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=