Vetnews | Julie 2026 20 « BACK TO CONTENTS Comparing undesirable behaviours between ‘designer’ Poodle-cross dogs... <<< 19 Leading Article trainability as well as higher separation-related problems and higher non-social fear scores. Additionally, the findings reveal that the owner’s age and whether the respondent worked in the canine/ animal care sector also had significant associations with C-BARQ scores, with younger owners reporting higher levels of dog-directed aggression and more serious separation-related problems, but also higher trainability scores. In contrast, respondents who worked in the canine/animal care sector reported lower touch sensitivity and lower social fear scores, consolidating previous research into canine behaviour that found an association with dogs displaying a lower level of undesirable behaviours and owners working in the canine sector [63]. Impact of health on behaviour Overall disorder prevalence was the covariate with the greatest association within the ANOVA analysis of behaviour subscale scores. Overall disorder prevalence is a proxy summary metric for overall health, which is increasingly recognised as an important contributing factor towards higher undesirable behaviour scores in dogs, particularly disorders associated with stress and pain [64–70]. Large-scale empirical studies have reported statistical associations between the presence of specific health problems and undesirable behaviours. For example, atopic dermatitis in dogs has been reported as associated with higher levels of undesirable behaviours such as excitability and reduced trainability [68], and anxiety and feardriven behaviours [71]. Designer-crossbreeds in the current study cohort had higher odds of skin disorders such as atopic dermatitis and otitis externa than their progenitors [20], which may contribute to their elevated levels of undesirable behaviours. These associations between physical health problems and undesirable behaviours suggest that owners of designer-crossbreeds who perceive problematic behaviours in their dogs should first consider seeking veterinary advice to diagnose any underlying physical health conditions that could be contributing to their dog’s behaviours. Influence of provenance on behaviour Another covariate that had notable associations with behaviour was whether the owner had seen the puppy with its mother on the day of collection, a proxy of illegal puppy sales in England under Lucy’s Law [72]. Not seeing the mother during the collection of the puppy was linked to lower trainability scores in all comparisons between the designer-crossbreeds and their progenitor breeds. Additionally, not seeing the puppy’s mother on collection of the puppy was associated with higher scores of owner- directed aggression and excitability in the Cockapoo and progenitor breed comparisons, higher separation-related problem scores in the Labradoodle and progenitor breed comparisons and higher dog rivalry scores in the Cavapoo and progenitor breed comparisons. This reinforces previous results that indicate viewing a puppy without their mother is associated with a higher level of undesirable behaviour in the future [73]. The current study’s results further consolidate earlier findings [1] that designer-crossbreed owners are less likely to see the mother of the puppy on the day of collection compared to purebred owners. By neglecting this key pre-purchasing behaviour, designercrossbreed owners not only risk supporting the illegal puppy trade but also compromising their own dog’s welfare. Evidence suggests purchasing puppies from poor welfare sources has long-term negative behavioural and health outcomes, including for puppies purchased from pet shops [62,74,75], puppy farms [76], purchased without their mother and father present [73,77], or purchased underage [78]. All dog owners, especially designer-crossbreed owners, must therefore adhere to puppy purchasing guidance. Gun dog behaviour and training Cocker Spaniels and Labrador Retrievers are classified as gun dogs, one of the seven breed groups recognised by the UK Kennel Club [79]. Owners of both Cocker Spaniel and Labrador Retriever dogs were significantly more likely to use a combination of reward-andaversive than reward-only based training methods compared to the Poodle and associated designer-crossbreed owners. The original role of gun dogs to locate and/or retrieve live game necessitated high levels of training. A major early training “guideline” (1952) for gun dogs was a book by Moxon (1952) “, Gundogs: Training and Field Trials” [80] that promoted methods that teach the dog “right” and “wrong” via the precise administration of physical punishment. While from the mid-20th century onwards, training of companion dogs more generally in the UK shifted to focus more on building relationships using reward-based methods, training cultures for gun dogs and working dogs have anecdotally remained focused on functionality and utility, perpetuating the use of aversive methods. This is despite aversive training methods (using positive punishment and negative reinforcement) having since been criticised for harming dog welfare and safety in the wider sector, e.g., [81,82], supported by scientific studies documenting negative welfare effects [83–86]. Both Labrador Retrievers and Cocker Spaniels in the current study scored better in trainability than their designer Poodle-crossbreed counterparts; however, while seemingly a positive result, this effect may result from forced suppression of ‘disobedient’ behaviours that can increase stress and cause a more negative mood state [86,87]. Many owners use aversive training techniques for perceived faster and more effective outcomes than positive reinforcement training methods [83]. However, research shows reward-based training is not only more effective than aversive training, but it can also help build a stronger dog-owner relationship and improve trust [83,84,88]. Consequently, owners of Cockapoos and Labradoodles (crossbreeds with gun dog parentage) should not interpret the finding of increased trainability in these breeds to suggest that aversive methods will help with their dog’s training. Instead, owners are encouraged to seek professional and welfare-focused training guidance from either accredited dog behaviourists
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=