Vetnews | Julie 2026 18 « BACK TO CONTENTS Comparing undesirable behaviours between ‘designer’ Poodle-cross dogs... <<< 17 scales compared and exhibited less undesirable behaviours in just 17.9% (7/39) of behaviour scales, despite perceived positive behavioural traits being a major driver of acquisition for designer crossbreed dogs [1]. Several patterns were notable in the behaviours that differed between the designer Poodle-crosses and the purebred parents. All three designer-crossbreed breeds exhibited significantly more non-social fear (e.g., fear of inanimate stimuli such as traffic, loud/sudden noises, novel objects/contexts), separation-related problems (e.g., undesirable behaviours such as excessive vocalisation and destructiveness when separated from their owner) and excitability (e.g., strong reactions to exciting/ arousing events such as walks, car trips, doorbells and visitors) compared to their non-Poodle progenitors. Fear-related behaviours represent potentially serious welfare concerns that could reflect poorer emotional health in these dogs and could negatively impact the dog-owner bond [34] and owner wellbeing [35]. However, several earlier studies [36] have shown that remarkably few owners seek veterinary or other professional help or advice to manage these three important behavioural issues. A UK-based study investigating fear responses to noises in domestic dogs revealed that fewer than a third of dog owners sought professional advice regarding treating their dog’s response to noises [37]. Owners of designercrossbreeds should be mindful that displaying these behaviours likely indicates their dog is experiencing negative emotions such as fear, anxiety and/or panic, which should be prioritised with similar consideration as any physical ailment to maintain good welfare. Canine behaviourists and veterinary professionals can support designer- crossbreed owners by increasing awareness of the serious negative impacts of these undesirable behaviours upon their dogs and offer appropriate therapies to address them [38]. Behavioural variability between individual designercrossbreed breeds There was considerable variability in the levels of undesirable behaviours shown between the three designer-crossbreed breeds. This suggests that designer-crossbred dogs should not be considered as a homogeneous group from a behavioural perspective. Cockapoos displayed the most undesirable behaviours of the three designer-crossbreeds studied (compared to the purebred progenitors). When compared to Cocker Spaniels and Poodles (2 x 12 C-BARQ behaviours), Cockapoos differed in 16/24 behaviour scale comparisons, exhibiting more undesirable behaviour in all 16 comparisons. Cavapoos differed in 12/24 behavioural scale comparisons (2 x 12 C-BARQ behaviours), exhibiting more undesirable behaviour for 11/12 differing comparisons. In contrast, Labradoodles differed in 11/24 behaviour scale comparisons (2 x 12 C-BARQ behaviours) but only displayed more undesirable behaviour than their progenitors in five comparisons, while exhibiting less undesirable behaviour in six comparisons. Except for better trainability in Cavapoos compared to one of its progenitor breeds (the CKCS), the Labradoodle was the only designer-crossbreed to show less undesirable behaviour than its purebred parents in ≥ 1 behaviour scale. Consequently, from these results, it is evident that each new designer- crossbreed needs its own evidence base and extrapolating information from other designer-crossbreeds should be done with caution. The results of the current study offer little support for the study hypothesis that specific Poodle-crosses score intermediately for all C-BARQ scales compared to their relevant progenitor breeds. That study hypothesis was based on an earlier C-BARQ analysis, which reported that Labradoodles scored intermediately between their parent breeds, the Poodle and Labrador Retriever [13]. Instead, our results suggest that the behaviour of this emerging designer Poodle- crossbreed demographic is generally worse than that of their progenitor breeds. However, in the current study, it was evident that Labradoodles differed less in the undesirable behaviour comparisons with their purebred progenitors, unlike the other designer-crossbreeds. This somewhat supports the findings of Shouldice et al (2019) in Labradoodles and highlights the importance of acknowledging disparity between designercrossbreed breeds rather than expecting all Poodle-crosses to exhibit the same behaviours. Factors influencing behavioural differences between designer crossbreeds and purebred progenitors The reasons behind this disparity between Labradoodles and the other two smaller designer-crossbreeds are not clear, but one possibility is that Labradoodles were established earlier than Cockapoos and Cavapoos (as evidenced by the lowest level of F1 crosses in this study) and have undergone more generations of selection towards more desirable behavioural phenotypes than the other two designer crossbreeds. The impact of genetic inheritance of certain behaviours should be further considered. For example, studies exploring the presence of Insulin-like Growth Factor-1 (IGF1) in smaller-sized dog breeds suggest that the IGF-1 gene may have pleiotropic effects in miniature and toy dog breeds, causing these dog types to display more fearful, excitable or reactive behaviours [10,39,40]. The Cockapoo and Cavapoo are physically smaller-sized dogs owing to their Poodle progenitor being more likely to have been the Toy or Miniature Poodle (e.g., 41.50% of Cavapoos in the current study had Toy Poodle parentage), with serum levels of IGF1 protein found to correlate with body size in Toy, Miniature and Standard Poodles [39]. This could partly explain why the Cockapoo and Cavapoo display more undesirable behaviours compared to the Labradoodle, as a larger designer-crossbreed. Size is an influential factor in undesirable behaviour, with previous studies finding that small dogs were twice as likely to show human-directed aggression compared to large dogs, with 30.8% of small dogs exhibiting this behaviour compared to 14.5% of large dogs and 19.4% of medium dogs [40]. That same study found that small (23.1%) and medium (25.8%) size dogs more commonly exhibited aggression toward objects in motion compared with large dogs (10.8%). Other ownerreported studies have similarly reported small dogs to be rated as more disobedient, more excitable and more nervous by their owners [10,41]. A correlation between small dog size and higher levels of undesirable behaviours could also reflect environmental influences, given that behaviour is a multifactorial trait and that owners are reported to interact differently with smaller versus larger dogs. For example, small dogs have been reported to receive less formal training than large dogs [41,42] and are walked less frequently [43]. In addition, owners of smaller dogs have been Leading Article
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=