VN July 2025

Vetnuus | July 2025 13 The top theme across the papers focused on the effects of vector distribution and climate change focuses on different aspects related to the “pathogen” including pathogen prevalence. This may reflect the importance of disease and/or pathogen surveillance systems in wildlife health. Documenting the presence or absence of pathogens has always been central to surveillance, however, there is growing recognition that surveillance systems must move beyond simply “putting points on a map” or “doing surveillance for surveillance sake” and instead be used to help generate information that can support evidence-based recommendations for the protection and promotion of healthy wildlife populations [5, 8]. For example, the collection of long-term baseline health data including information on pathogen occurrence is rarely prioritised, making it difficult to track trends over time, disentangle climate-associated impacts, and draw evidence-based conclusions. Wildlife exists in complex systems and how health is quantified or assessed can vary depending on the definition of health being used and at what scale you are looking at. This variation in scale is captured in the theme focused on “levels” with some papers looking at an individual or species level versus others that look at a population or community level. Quantifying health at different scales plays a huge role in determining how health is measured and moving beyond a focus on disease processes. For example, health metrics such as blood chemistry are focused on an individual animal while at a species level metrics such as population counts or species interactions are more important [2, 21]. Several individualbased health metrics were identified as themes including body condition, body size or mass, physiological stress responses, and host behavioural responses, while it is not clear what other metrics were used to study health impacts across the different levels. Identifying wildlife health metrics, across different levels, allows actionable health frameworks that can scale from the animal (e.g., targeted antibiotic use) to the ecosystem (e.g., providing corridors of connectivity between optimal habitats). These approaches can move us beyond the detection of pathogens and their pathology towards healthy wildlife [1]. Understanding health effects at different levels can help identify relevant health metrics and targets, which is critical to guide potential management actions that may be used to reach those targets [14]. In a review of 261 studies looking at health assessments for population monitoring in noncaptive vertebrate species, the most common metrics used included taxa blood analysis, body composition assessments, physical examination, and faecal analyses however, only a limited number of papers discussed how these metrics could be used to inform decisionmaking processes without further integrating a physiological or ecological understanding of species resilience [21]. In addition, these metrics are all focused on the individual level whereas wildlife management often occurs at the population level or above, with a recent shift to adaptive management approaches at the ecosystem level as a way of managing for resilience. Taking an ecological perspective on management is a more holistic approach compared to using single species to guide decision-making as it considers the problem in context including both important ecological interactions and interactions at the human-wildlife interface (Mascia et al., [25]. It is also necessary to explain in more details the inclusion (eligibility) criteria and reason why large proportion of the articles were excluded from the study. Consequently, please address potential concerns that may arise from th2003). Additional themes, concerned with indirect effects, long-term effects, cascading effects, or sublethal effects, further highlight some of the challenges in defining and measuring wildlife health and the potential additive effects of climate change on health which are often not considered in health frameworks. When examining the themes identified in this study, it is important to consider the limitations both in the search strategy and AIbased thematic analysis. A variety of keywords were used to capture the central concepts: wildlife, health, and climate change. However, with any search strategy, it is hard to assess the scope and magnitude of papers that have been missed or the biases introduced by the keywords. This may be of particular importance when considering the expanding definition of wildlife health and how defining health is complicated by the different terminology used across disciplines. For example, an ecologist may be more likely to use terms such as “fitness” instead of “health.” Nevertheless, it is important to note that out of the 2,249 records that resulted from the literature search, only 16.5% (372/2,249) remained after applying the eligibility criteria suggesting that the search terms could have been further assessed to help narrow the search and reduce the number of papers that were outside the scope of this review. A large proportion of the papers were removed during the inclusion/exclusion process because they discussed how climate change would potentially impact their findings, particularly concerning the prevalence of pathogens and/or diseases, but did not directly investigate climate change impacts on wildlife health outcomes. These papers highlight the difficulty in assessing the impact of climate change without a large amount of retrospective or baseline data for both health and climate. The eligibility criteria may have also resulted in papers being excluded from the thematic analysis inappropriately, however, having such criteria is important to help standardise the inclusion/exclusion process between reviewers. It is also important to acknowledge that by using an AI tool for autocoding themes, there is a risk of misclassification as the algorithm is based on pattern recognition and lacks human insight or context. In this study, many of the auto-coded noun phrases were either moved into different themes or broken down/split to create a new noun phrase. For example, the noun phrase “body temperature” was initially included under the theme “temperature” but was combined with the noun phrases “body size/mass” and “body condition” to create a new parent theme with the understanding that they are all related to physiological measurements. This highlights the importance of manually reviewing the themes. Nevertheless, the use of AI auto-coding followed by a manual review still takes considerably less time than manually coding the themes and showcases how AI tools can facilitate the initial stages of qualitative data analysis, especially in cases where there is a large amount of data. An important next step in this analysis would be to build a thematic map or network to start exploring the relationships between codes and themes [7]. For instance, in this analysis, moose (Alces alces) were one of only two wildlife species identified in a theme; however, on further exploration, you can see that all the papers identified under the theme “moose” are also captured under the themes related to “increasing temperatures” and “Dermacentor tick species”. This is unsurprising given the evidence for increasing winter tick (Dermacentor albipictus) burdens due to increasing temperatures and its impact on calve survival [9, 19] and adult cow reproduction rates [11]. A thematic map would also help reflect the complexity of wildlife health and further highlight potential knowledge gaps. For example, “increasing temperatures” was the >>>14 Leading Article

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=