Vetnuus | April 2025 15 Article the perception and evaluation of veterinarians on the role of volunteers, by focusing on the hierarchy charts of intersecting codes and analysing the Items coded for the code Relationship with volunteers, it becomes apparent that it is also associated with Emotion codes, code Beliefs toward violence, and code Financial matters. The participants mostly speak about their positive attitude regarding the volunteers’ motivation and share stories about volunteers who have brought stray animals to their clinics. “I believe volunteers’ motivation is very noble. Good. Who will take care of animals anyway?” Veterinarians acknowledge that financial considerations significantly impact both the field of veterinary medicine as a whole and the capacity to offer aid to homeless animals specifically. Simultaneously, they dismiss criticism from volunteers of their refusal to provide medical care to stray animals without compensation. This subject will emerge as a major topic in discussions on discrepancies with activists and aligns with Kipperman, Rollin, & Martin’s (2021) findings about the perception of veterinarians as professionals placing more importance on financial profit rather than animal welfare. Contradictions with volunteers persist with a predominant focus on codes such as Negative emotions, Perspectives on violence, Pain, Financial matters, and Rights of homeless animals. The subject of the Euthanasia code also arises. This concept can also be represented through detailed and engaging stories, explaining the vets’ belief that it is rude to claim that veterinarians pursue their job solely for financial gain even from a strictly economic perspective: an individual dedicates 6 years to studying and continues to invest significant effort in their profession throughout their life after graduation. Also because of emotional stress the suicide rates are high: “Activists see animals that are stray hurting or that they are doing well in their new homes. But they do not see veterinary medicine as a whole. <…> To see an animal suffering from the same illnesses and to fight for that animal, along with the animal and its owners, is an incredibly stressful job. <…> I can say that it is hard on an emotional level. We see deaths every day, and each case is different. And we all must deal with pain, suffering, blood, and other fluids every day.” The increased level of stress and emotional burden experienced by veterinarians is consistent with the conclusions drawn by RathwellDeault et al. (2017), who observed that veterinarians encounter substantial ethical issues, particularly in relation to euthanasia. This concept is expanded upon under the perspective of viewing volunteering as a sort of business. Within the context of this perception, such codes as Negative emotions, Pain, Violence, Financial matters, Laws, and Euthanasia are prevalent. “The statutes of these volunteer groups are great, and they ask for donations. But, as you may have noticed, they’re all pretty weird in the end. It turns out that they show strange images of animals that don’t exist or are made up. I think that as long as someone can use an animal to make money, there is a very, very high chance that they will do this.” Veterinarians argue that volunteers use aged or chronically ill animals to get donations from sympathetic individuals. According to the participants, it is not worthwhile to make extensive efforts to prolong the life of a disabled animal, especially if it is unlikely to be adopted. Instead, it would be better to allocate the received donations towards sterilising and treating young animals that can be easily socialised. “I don’t like putting terrible pictures all over the internet to get money from people. At the same time, if they are young kittens - they need to be vaccinated, they need to be castrated, they need to be put together everywhere - and people will take them.” However, there is also a common veterinarians’ devotion to volunteers, exemplified by codes such as Positive emotions, Role in the preservation of animal rights, and Beliefs about homeless animals’ rights. Like volunteers, doctors hold the belief that homeless animals possess inherent rights (some sources argue that it is more accurate to refer to them as “freedoms” rather than “rights”), which are frequently constrained or violated because of human actions. Considering comparing the rights of domestic and homeless animals, several veterinarians claimed that domestic animals also lack certain rights that stray animals possess, such as the freedom to hunt and take extensive walks. “I think that stray cats that live outdoors are happier than cats that live in one-room apartments and can’t go anywhere. This is just my view, though.” The belief in the inherent rights or freedoms of homeless animals supports the broader ethical framework within which veterinarians operate, as elucidated by Graaf (2005) and McGlacken, Anderson, & HobsonWest (2023). This framework emphasises the advocacy role of veterinarians, not only in relation to pets but also to homeless animals, linking their professional obligations to wider animal welfare objectives. While examining veterinarians’ perspectives on their role in addressing violence against homeless animals, NVivo provided a visualisation that highlighted the key role of veterinarians in educating pet owners and society. According to the respondents, the veterinarian’s function is defined by expertise, since the owner lacks or has minimal knowledge about the animals, making it challenging for them to comprehend some aspects. This issue is not only pertinent to medical treatment and animal welfare but also from the perspective of environmental health. By addressing the health of individual patients, it contributes to the overall wellbeing of society. An example of this is the prevention of zoonotic diseases. This educational role of veterinarians is crucial, as highlighted by Dolby & Litster (2015), who argue that veterinarians should not only be seen as medical professionals but also as educators who can influence public perceptions and behaviours towards animal welfare. This dual role can help bridge the gap between veterinary practice and animal rights activism. Semi-structured interviews allowed the building of trust with respondents and enabled the exploration of intricate intersections between perspectives on the rights of homeless animals and their choices within the context of medical reality. All informants acknowledge the existence of rights (or freedoms) in homeless animals, which are violated by individuals (including former owners) in numerous ways. The empathetic dedication to animals in need of medical assistance, along with an understanding of their role in helping reduce pain, confronts the challenging truth of the monetary costs of veterinary medicine. This growing mental load and the resulting burnout are critical issues that reflect the broader ethical quandaries and emotional burdens faced by veterinarians, as detailed by Moses, Malowney, & Wesley Boyd (2018). Although the veterinarian’s main mission is for the welfare of animals rather than focus on financial concerns, our study revealed that Bridging Compassion and Commerce: Veterinarians’ Ethical Dilemmas in Providing Care for Homeless Animals <<<14
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=