VN April 2025

Vetnuus | April 2025 13 Article >>>14 companion animal owners (Graaf, 2005; McGlacken, Anderson & HobsonWest, 2023), the sociological understanding of the involvement of veterinarians in the realm of homeless animal rights remains limited. It can be assumed that the reason for these limitations lies in the lack of scholarly attention within the social sciences to the involvement of veterinarians in animal rights activism during the 2000s. This can be attributed to the historical concentration of the veterinary profession on animal health, as noted by Jones (2003). In recent years, there has been an increase in attention towards veterinarians, prompting public discourse on the legal and ethical treatment of animals and their welfare within society (Grimm, 2014). This is due to the societal expectation that veterinarians should serve just as advocates for animals (De Paula Vieira & Anthony, 2020) in safeguarding the wellbeing of their patients (Rathwell-Deault et al., 2017). The studies can be categorised into two distinct areas of focus: addressing ethical quandaries within veterinary practices and redefining the professional responsibilities of veterinary practitioners. Existing research primarily centres on the ethical predicaments encountered by veterinary doctors in their daily practice, particularly when confronted with conflicting values and difficult decision-making processes (Tannenbaum, 1995; Morgan & McDonald, 2007; DeSantis Kerr et al., 2016; Moses, 2018; Perssons et al., 2023). This body of literature predominantly focuses on the ethical considerations surrounding the convenient euthanasia of animals that are physically and psychologically healthy (Morgan, 2009; Rollin, 2011; Moses, Malowney & Boyd, 2018; Arbe Montoya et al., 2019; Dürnberger, 2020; Glaesmer et al., 2021). The study conducted by Rathwell-Deault et al. (2017) examined the ethical dilemma of veterinarians in Quebec when required to euthanise a physically and psychologically healthy animal). The findings indicated that a majority of veterinarians would opt to carry out euthanasia of healthy animals due to the perceived lack of the animal’s moral value, which is influenced by the bond between the owner and the animal. According to Jacobsson & Lindblom (2016), the legislation governs the overall parameters of euthanasia, including the necessary conditions and medical protocols. However, it is important to note that the ultimate determination of whether to proceed with euthanasia or not remains contingent upon individual perspectives rather than being solely dictated by local legislation. The study conducted by Kipperman, Morris, & Rollin (2018) has provided insights into the perspectives held by veterinarians concerning the practice of euthanising animals. A significant proportion of the participants, specifically 45 per cent, expressed their agreement with the notion that they occasionally employ euthanasia in challenging situations, even when it may not align with the optimal welfare of the patient. Within veterinary literature, two distinct models outline the actions a doctor may take when faced with an ethical dilemma. The first model, known as the anthropocentric action model, does not consider the interests and needs of animals due to their status as property (RathwellDeault et al., 2017). In contrast, the second model, referred to as the biocentric model, acknowledges animals as moral beings, equivalent to humans (Rollin, 2006). These models provide a connection between veterinarians and proponents of animal rights, like Singer (1975), Regan (1983), and Francione (2000), while also establishing a connection between veterinary medicine and social studies. According to Siegford, Cottee, & Widowski (2010), since 2005 there has been evidence of a shift in the professional responsibilities of veterinarians. For example, in a study on redefining professional responsibilities, Dolby & Litster (2015) focused on the educational function of veterinarians in the domains of animal welfare and the human-animal link. They put forward the argument that veterinarians should not be perceived only as medical personnel, but also as volunteers. The survey revealed limited agreement among participants on the subject matter of animal welfare and the relationship between humans and animals. The emphasis placed by veterinarians on the human perspective rather than the animal perspective within the realm of animal rights activism was underscored. Additionally, Dolby & Litster (2015) have highlighted that veterinarians still do not perceive themselves as educators of pet owners. The current study has also failed to consider the matter of animal value as seen by owners, resulting in the researchers drawing the inference that stray dogs had diminished worth due to the absence of an emotional link to people. Nevertheless, while this assertion aligns with the attitude of volunteers who assist with the care of homeless animals (Šeiko & Ņikišins, TBP), it would be hasty to generalise that all veterinarians adhere to this standpoint. An answer provided by Rollin (2005) in the Canadian Veterinary Journal addressed the ethical inquiry regarding the professional and ethical responsibilities of veterinarians. The question posed was whether veterinarians should allow the population of cats to be subject to “natural selection” or bear the economic burden of treating stray cats. Rollin emphasised that the veterinarian’s foremost obligation is to alleviate suffering by euthanising animals that have little chance of recovery and to prioritise the sterilisation of a significant number of animals. The application of the World Small Animal Veterinary Association’s guideline to safeguard animals from pain, injury, anxiety, and discomfort is evident in this particular instance (Terrestrial Animal Health Code, 2016; Ryan et al., 2019). Rollin (2011) suggests that veterinarians might employ innovative strategies to encourage public donations for the care of injured and unidentified animals brought to clinics by volunteers who lack the financial means to cover the expenses. The literature analysis poses a question that this study must answer: does a moral dilemma arise when volunteers bring homeless animals (usually cats) to clinics for treatment? In the case of stray cats, it is not feasible to attribute the concept of property status to an animal. Some volunteers in the Šeiko & Ņikišins (TBP) study proposed that veterinarians adopt the role of medical specialists and are not interested in animal rights advocacy. This unflattering attitude can be caused by the high costs of veterinary services and volunteers’ endeavours to fight not only for animal rights, but also for donations to cover treatment costs (Kipperman, Rollin, & Martin, 2021). Additionally, it suggests a potential conflict between volunteers assisting homeless animals and veterinary professionals. Therefore, this study aims to enhance the overall understanding of the ethical dilemmas veterinary doctors face while providing

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTc5MDU=